.
Feedback

Community Voice: Education Before Extracurriculars

Patch gives residents a chance to speak out as a part of its education series leading up to the May 17 budget vote and Board of Education election.

Every parent hopes to ensure their child thrives in his educational setting. 

Since the second grade, when his national scores were shown not in numbers, but in asterisks, I began a journey to discover how to properly educate a child with an IQ more than 3 standard deviations above the norm.  Instead of thriving, the query evolved into how does such a child survive in a school setting designed for the norm and the special education students. 

The answers are unfortunate but his success is not due to public education.  When a community demotes academics to the lesser of the extracurricular programming provided by schools, waving the extracurricular banners as more important, several things occur: the national scholars are lost, the country becomes less competitive globally, our best colleges are overrun by the more motivated, more competitive international students. 

Of course extracurricular activities are important, but most important, before any discussion, is whether the school's foundation, its student's core subjects, and its difficulty level is sound.  Is there business math, social science exploration, investment curriculum, honor roll & perfect attendance recognition, peer guidance, peer tutoring, advanced foreign language, AP offerings, BOCES counseling and requirements beyond what the minimum laws require to push students academically?

Not every kid will lead the class in academics, but it is unforgivable in America when a school's design lets slip this generation's Einsteins through the cracks into mediocre oblivion. These children, if left to their own devices are doomed to be bored out of their minds in unmotivated classrooms, will never be celebrated as the next American inventors or heroes, simply because the student-athlete's budget concerns dominated the community discussion boards and pushed votes towards obliterating the dominance of American excellence in academic achievement. 

Less than 1 percent of any graduating class will make it to a professional sport level. We ask our schools to make our student body 100 percent employable, not after college, but upon high school graduation. 

What is the sense, really beyond happier childhoods, to devote most of the discretionary budgets to sports?  The goals of education are not to field as many teams as possible, but to educate and make our children employable in a global economy. For purposes of debate, if you advocate for more teams do you realize you are advocating for less skilled, less competitive future employees?

Boards of education must stay true to the goals of the promise of educating all students of all abilities, and honor the celebrations of not just the fastest students, but also the smartest students. 

-

Constance F. Roland

Wantagh resident in Seaford School District

Education Man April 29, 2011 at 02:48 pm
I never was never ceased to be amazed at the sports parents who made such a big thing of this subject. They were more concerned with 7th grade volleyball then grades anyway. And of course NONE of the children I ever saw come thru Seaford went onto the major leaques or the NFL anyways. As a matter of fact most failed to even get sports based scholarship money. They are just re-living their childhood thru their kids. SAD.
Steve April 29, 2011 at 03:56 pm
I understand your point Education Man...but to be honest a majority of the parents have no visions of professional sports, myself included. Playing organized sports from youth all the way up to High School does much more than keep children physically fit (which by the way is very important especially in today's day and age of technology).
Sports teach kids to never give up...it is competitive just like life when you are competing for a job. Do you want to be that kid in rightfield for the last 3 innings of the game or do you want to be a starter...do you want to be an assistant or the boss in a specific job? Sports teach us how to communicate. You learn how to be a teamate thru communication and leadership. A child needs to learn how to interact with all types of personalities and sports can help. TO BE CONT'D
Steve April 29, 2011 at 03:57 pm
There are so many things they may learn in sports and perhaps not the classroom...such as developing positive character traits, teamwork, taking risks, discipline, concentration, strategy...etc. This is not to say they cannot learn many of these in the classroom, however just as a gifted student is better suited for classroom learning, some children are better suited for learning outside the classroom...and athletics are that avenue of learning.
Some of the more successful people I know were not so-called successful in the classroom as students...they learned valuable traits that helped them succeed from other ways...and some from athletics. The big issue here is obviously the money and how much of it goes to our school taxes...but do not be so narrow minded.
MAC April 29, 2011 at 07:33 pm
Another important aspect of after school athletics is to keep children off the streets. Drug use is a very serious problem, and studies have shown that children who participate in sports are less likely to get involved in drugs. Finally " Educated Man" should educate himself about the history of Seaford sports. He says in capital letter that NONE of children have gone on to the major leagues of the NFL and that is NOT true.
I am an Educated Man April 30, 2011 at 12:31 am
Yada Yada Yada..and every year I look at the ever growing list of our graduates attending Nassau Community College..Seaford should be ashamed BUT they dont care because they're on vacation 5 months a year. Wake up folks......we need better education for ALL the kids.
MAC April 30, 2011 at 03:38 pm
Once again an Educated Man has reveled his ignorance. First of all, there is nothing wrong with attending Nassau Community College. For many people it is the only financially viable option. Now I know Educated Man knows everything about Seaford, but is he aware that in the 2010 graduating class, there were two students who were going to Harvard, one to the Univ. Of Pennsylvania, another going to NYU and many other top tier universities. This year's class has students going to Georgetown, NYU, Boston Univ., Syracuse Univ. and SUNY Binghamton to name a few. I'm am not saying that Seaford is the best school on Long Island, nor is it the worst. There is room for improvement of course. I just wanted to point out a few incorrect facts being posted on this blog. As a life long Seaford resident and a Seaford graduate, I do know what I'm talking about when it comes to Seaford.
I really I'm an Educated Man April 30, 2011 at 08:30 pm
First off Im NOT anti sports , sports are excellent at teaching life skills. What Iam "anti" is parents who get the panties in a wad over the possibility of canceling 7th grade volleyball, or cheer-leading over the firing of an excellent new teacher or cutting an educational class. That was my opinion and my pont. AND I really I'm an educated man. I attended St. Francis Prep HS as well as Fordham. AND from what I have seen having sent two of my three children thru Seaford High School ( my son attended Chaminade - you know MAC that lousy school where they all get scholarships ), I really do not think we as tax payers are well served by this district in any way. And I will add that I have heard several parents in my daughters sophomore class lament at NOT having sent them to private school.
MAC April 30, 2011 at 10:51 pm
I understand that you are an educated man, but my PONT is that I get annoyed at people who make these broad generalizations. Like "none" of the children have made it to professional sports, and that all of the teachers, only care about is their 5 months off. I agree what was said in the original article, and that the major emphasis should be providing the best education possible to our children. All of my children are attending school in Seaford and I could make a list of teachers that are not that good. However I can make a longer list of teachers that do an excellent job. I'm glad that you send your son to Chaminade, it is an excellent school. But somehow you're making an inference that I said it was a lousy school. At no point in my blog I said anything bad about private education. The only one disparaging any school was you making fun of Nassau Community College. Also St. Francis Prep and Fordham are both excellent schools. I attended a Jesuit college myself. But it was at Seaford High School where I learned at you do not start a sentence with the word "And".
Fordham '85 May 1, 2011 at 01:39 am
Sorry MAC I spent to much time in those Fordham bars, and was not an English major. LOL.
My son attends there now, and they are all big shots and go "The City". LOL. I agree that the majority of the teachers my children had going through the Seaford schools were all dedicated, excellent teachers. HOWEVER we are in really tough times now, and this is a middle to lower middle class town that can not afford to be socked with a enormous school tax increase. If it continues more and more people will abandon the public school system. Their union, as well as our school board need to take direct action to restore confidence. Sadly I do not believe either will occur.
MAC May 1, 2011 at 03:42 am
Finally you are saying something that I can agree with 100%. You don't need to tell me how touch times are now. I am working two jobs just to make ends meet. As you said the union and school board need to take some action, that is why this upcoming school board election is so important. People need to get to know who is running, what their positions are, and choose the candidate that they feel will serve us, the tax paying community.
Katie May 3, 2011 at 03:47 pm
MEET THE SEAFORD BOARD OF EDUCATION CANDIDATES...ask questions and get educated on the qualifiations of the candidates...THIS WEDNESDAY, MAY 4 AT 7:30 AT THE SEAFORD MANOR SCHOOL...these are the candidates that will be on the board negociating and voting on the next set of teacher's contracts.
bill May 4, 2011 at 02:13 am
Wow.
Educated man? I don't think so. I know many people who have sent their sons to chaminade. It's a good school. However, if you're fortunate to have a smart, motivated child, they will do very well at Seaford. The school provides a safe place to learn, and those who want to learn, will do well. The cream always rises to the top, regardless of the school. As a counterpoint to the uneducated man, I know many kids that after attending private school for a year, have come back to Seaford ( and done very well). To Kate, although I believe candidates night is interesting, the questions are reviewed before being asked to the candidates. The really interesting ones, that have even a hint of controversy, are shelved. Still, in can be an illuminating night. Do you think they'll allow a question to Ms. Phillips questioning her motives for running for the board ( she's a teacher in Farmingdale and a building rep! )
Lorraine DeVita May 17, 2011 at 11:49 am
RISE AND SHINE SEAFORD, even in this dismal weather it is imperative you don your raincoat grab an umbrella and GO VOTE.. The UTS is counting on a LOW TURNOUT. Today the phones will be ringing all over Seaford and probably all over LI. Regardless of who the calls originate from it works to everyones advantage. Reminding people to go VOTE. Your Voice needs to be heard not just here on the Patch but in the classrooms , the ADMIN offices and in the sanctum/sanctorium of the UTS! USE your VOTE.
Dont let organized bargaining units continue to run rough shod over the community, drain our resources and suck the life out of education for our kids and our pocketbooks. You have a choice: continue the insanity or VOTE to let EVERYONE know that We have had enough, we Cant afford to be apathtic any longer. GO VOTE! Remember its a bad hair day for all of us well except perhaps my husband who is folically challenged , but irregardless a little water shouldnt prevent ANYONE from getting out to VOTE! Strap those kids in those car seats, babysit for a neighbor if you have to CARPOOL if neccessary but get out there and VOTE!
Denise May 19, 2011 at 04:21 pm
Lori Fritsch- This is your second chance to prove yourself to the community and the very children you serve. Go to the board and fall on the sword. Tell them you were wrong. Seaford demands a freeze, nothing less. A freeze means just that, ZERO with no strings attached. No slight of the hand, no attachments. A ZERO means ZERO for the entire year. No increases in steps and no salary. THAT’S a FREEZE. THAT’S A ZERO! Take it directly to your membership and ask them. They are angry with you and your board. Save education, save a teacher’s job, save Seaford! There are some teachers who are getting fired twice in 12 months because of you and your actions. There are some very GOOD teachers who are 1st year employees and wished they never came here because you sold them out!
We hope you pull through and come to realize Seaford is a great place to work and an even better place to raise children. Don’t play dumb either and pretend you didn’t read this. If there is a teacher reading this make sure Lori gets this message TODAY!! Everyone, please chime in and support this request by replying to this comment. Help support our children’s education and pressure Lori and the UTS board just like they pressured Ms Phillips to run. Lori Fritsch, don’t throw our children under the bus just like you threw Phillips under the bus. Take the FREEZE. Lori we demand an answer now. Help or don’t help. It’s your choice. How Seaford reacts will be based on your decision.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Wantagh-Seaford Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something